Not Your Grandma’s Market

The daily hubbub of the stock market has changed dramatically. The past 20 years, or 10, or even two have transformed the environment for public companies to raise and maintain equity capital. As investor relations professionals, we must study up.

(I’ve posted some personal viewpoints on regulatory expansion of trading here.)

This page is offered as a resource on the new world of trading, and points you to other resources to learn about changing market structure and activity.

SEC concept release January 14, 2010

In response to the 2007-09 market meltdown, the Securities and Exchange Commission is embarking on a broad review of equity market structure – with an eye to regulating venues and techniques. The SEC summarizes its approach in a press release, but the most informative read is the concept release itself (PDF file).

This 74-page narrative on changes in equity market structure provides a good primer on trading venues and activities, including statistical data on the market’s evolution. It offers concepts for new regulatory proposals – and an invitation for public comments. Three areas the SEC is considering regulating:

  • Banning flash orders, which enable a person who has not publicly displayed a quote to see orders less than a second before the public can trade with those orders. This gives an advantage to automated trading operations.
  • Strengthening transparency requirements for nonpublic trading interest, including “dark pools” of liquidity, alternative trading systems that match orders privately and do not display quotations to the public.
  • Launching a new SEC market structure initiative to strengthen the risk management controls of broker-dealers that provide market access.

The SEC is accepting comments, analysis and data submissions on all aspects of market structure – and its proposals – online or on paper, by April 21, 2010.

Excerpts from the SEC Concept Release

Since I find the concept release on market structure very informative, I’ll share a few excerpts of educational portions:

The transformation of equity trading has encompassed all types of U.S.-listed stocks. In recent years, however, it is perhaps most apparent in stocks listed on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”), which constitute nearly 80% of the capitalization of the U.S. equity markets. In contrast to stocks listed on the NASDAQ Stock Market LLC (“NASDAQ”), which for more than a decade have been traded in a highly automated fashion at many different trading centers, NYSE-listed stocks were traded primarily on the floor of the NYSE in a manual fashion until October 2006. At that time, NYSE began to offer fully automated access to its displayed quotations.  An important impetus for this change was the Commission’s adoption of Regulation NMS in 2005, which eliminated the trade-through protection for manual quotations that nearly all commenters believed was seriously outdated.

The changes in the nature of trading for NYSE-listed stocks have been extraordinary, as indicated by the comparisons of trading in 2005 and 2009 in Figures 1 through 5 below:

Figure 1 – NYSE executed approximately 79.1% of the consolidated share volume in its listed stocks in January 2005, compared to 25.1% in October 2009.                                                                                                                                                                              …

Figure 2 – NYSE’s average speed of execution for small, immediately executable (marketable) orders was 10.1 seconds in January 2005, compared to 0.7 seconds in October 2009.                                                                                                                                                                       …

Figure 3 – consolidated average daily share volume in NYSE-listed stocks was 2.1 billion shares in 2005, compared to 5.9 billion shares (an increase of 181%) in January through October 2009.                                                                                                                                     …

Figure 4 – consolidated average daily trades in NYSE-listed stocks was 2.9 million trades in 2005, compared to 22.1 million trades (an increase of 662%) in January through October 2009.                                                                                                                                                    …

Figure 5 – consolidated average trade size in NYSE-listed stocks was 724 shares in 2005, compared to 268 shares in January through October 2009.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 …

So automated trading tends to create much higher volume of trading, in smaller quantities, moving much faster and spread out among multiple electronic trading venues. The SEC provides an overview of where stock trading is taking place:

Trading Centers and Estimated % of Share Volume
in NMS Stocks – September 2009

Hit the books

In the spirit of educating ourselves, a pretty good book on the emergence of automated trading is Nerds on Wall Street: Math, Machines & Wired Markets by David Leinweber (Wiley, 2009). Another, which is more skeptical, is A Demon of Our Own Design: Markets, Hedge Funds, and the Perils of Financial Innovation by Richard Bookstaber (Wiley, 2007).

Seek out industry resources

Professional associations are providing quite a bit of information on the changes in trading – and monitoring and trying to influence the development of policy in Washington. Check out these industry resources:

Send your cards & letters to the SEC

The SEC’s concept release seeks out public comment on three issues related to the equity markets – the performance of the current market structure, high-frequency trading, and undisplayed liquidity – as well as any other aspect of the markets.

I hope this summary, which only skims the surface of changing market structure, is helpful. Please feel free to comment on this page, or contact me directly.

© 2010 Johnson Strategic Communications Inc.
except excerpts from SEC document


2 Responses to “Not Your Grandma’s Market”

  1. Let’s NOT squash trading « IR Café Says:

    […] That’s the start of a push for expanded regulation. I’ll post excerpts in a page called “Not Your Grandma’s Market,” but the full 74-page release is worth […]

  2. Tweets that mention Not Your Grandma’s Market « IR Café -- Says:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dick Johnson, Tim Wood. Tim Wood said: Excellent. RT @StrategicComm: It's not your grandma's market anymore. The new world of equity trading – #IR […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: