Bear market IR – is it different?

So the bear growls, claws, gnaws and gets most of us down – measured either by our emotional states or the stock prices that stare back at us from our screens. The S&P 500 is down 32% from a year ago. The Wall Street Journal must be running out of synonyms: shock, shake, mess, slide, crisis, meltdown, turmoil, crunch, plunge …

So far we haven’t seen Time or Newsweek cover stories pronouncing the “death of the stock market” – a traditional sign of investor capitulation and a bottom – so it’s a fair bet the negative environment will be with us awhile, despite the occasional bounce. No doubt more bad news awaits.

Accordingly, here are 10 ideas on doing investor relations in a bear market. Nothing unique or magical – a difficult market is by definition, well, difficult – but here are the thoughts of one IR guy who has been through a few market cycles:

… Stay visible (or get out there). Sure, it’s hard to tell a happy story when everyone’s scared to death. But a happy story isn’t the goal. At some point investors, especially professionals who may be keeping their powder dry right now, will be back in the buying mood. They should be getting to know you now.

… Be factual in your tone. The market ascribes credibility to executives who lay out the facts in a pretty blunt way. Presentations and publications should be fact-laden, not flashy, funny or visionary. You’re giving people data to evaluate your company in the midst of a fearful time. Their view of the broader market environment probably will determine when they’re in a buying mood, anyway.

… Don’t be quick to make promises. Suppose the financial turmoil turns into a real recession (as economists, not politicians, define it). Consumer spending could go in the tank and stay there. Business investment may be on hold. Earnings could go worst-case. Guidance based on economic assumptions may go awry – so at least lay out the assumptions for investors, if you’re going to forecast results or major events in the future.

… Do tell the long-term story. In spite of complaining about short-termism in the stock market, many CEOs and CFOs talk to investors as if the latest quarter, or the next, is the biggest deal for shareholders. You should ask, what is the key message? What will drive the value of this company? Odds are, it has to do with business trends that span several years, competitive position, innovative strategy and the like.

… Discuss the balance sheet. When investors are valuing stocks on their growth prospects, it’s about the P&L. But when the issue is survival, people need to understand the size and nature of the assets, and the size and nature of the liabilities. Safety (or lack of it) is found in the balance sheet.

… Give the bad with the good. Nothing erodes the trust of investors as much as management being in denial. Running the “sunshine pump” or trying to gloss over bad results damages a company’s credibility. Acknowledging problems and defining a plan of action builds confidence.

… Refute rumors quickly with the facts. As several of the Wall Street collapses have shown, rumors can aggravate business problems by undercutting the confidence of customers and investors. More than ever, a bear market is a time to monitor online and market “chatter” – and correct anything erroneous.

… Coordinate investor and media relations. It’s a small world. When a reporter is working on a story, he’ll call analysts and investors (friendly or unfriendly) looking for insight. And investors, in turn, pay attention to what the media says about a company. Companies should speak with one voice, and IR and PR should coordinate daily to plan responses on any issues lurking in the market.

… Polish up your Q&A. The issues are myriad: credit crunch, recession, your industry trend, consumer pullbacks, job cuts, commodity prices, political uncertainty, regulatory changes in the air. Best practices for IR include preparing a document with answers to the market’s most likely questions and concerns, running them through senior management and legal counsel, and distributing these messages to everyone in-house who answers questions from investors and the media.

… The story is the business, not the stock price. For anxious shareholders, the most urgent issue right now may be the amount of money they’re down on their investment. But for the company and more seasoned investors, the question is where the business stands today – and what management is doing for the future. Regardless of the drama in the stock market, for IROs the business is the message.

© Copyright 2008 Johnson Strategic Communications Inc.


Tags: , ,

9 Responses to “Bear market IR – is it different?”

  1. Dominic Jones Says:

    Lots of great advice here, Dick.

  2. How to do IR in a bear market | IR Web Report Says:

    […] recommend you add to your RSS reader, the president of Johnson Strategic Communications Inc. offers 10 ideas on doing IR in a bear market from “one IR guy who has been through a few market […]

  3. Jon Falk Says:

    “The story is the business, not the stock price.” I could not agree more.

    People want to understand a company beyond the numbers … right now they have to. It takes some work to articulate the value of a business beyond typical press releases and SEC documents, but for those that do the benefits are clear.

    Be true to what you should be talking about:
    1. Show your organization has a strategy and real goals in place.
    2. Show that you are implementing the strategy and connect it real world outcomes.
    3. Show that you have the right team to get the job done.

    Don’t leave your story up to the guesswork and speculation of others by not telling it. Be the one to tell your story on your terms…no one is better equipped to do so.

  4. Agoracom: Small Cap Investment Says:

    […] also refers to another pretty good list of IR best practices during market turmoil by Johnson Communications. You will note a lot of crossover with my list, as […]

  5. AGORACOM - George Says:

    Dick, great minds think alike. We published our own list today. We both touched on some common points and I picked up some new ones from your list.

    If I can add value here, it would be to stress the importance of Web 2.0 IR tools to quickly, efficiently and broadly communicate a company’s message.

    We just recorded 1.2 million investors that read 101 million pages of IR information via our IR communities. Traditional phone and e-mail solutions just can’t accelerate an IR message at these levels.


  6. From Wall Street to Zero Street « IR Café Says:

    […] offered some thoughts on potential IR messages and tactics in a bear market (here and here). And I welcome any ideas you might contribute to this […]

  7. Ugly « IR Café Says:

    […] impossible), or at least continue to build credibility and relationships with investors. See posts here and here. On the other side of this, we all hope to emerge looking – well, not so […]

  8. This isn’t good … « IR Café Says:

    […] shared some other ideas on “bear market IR” in earlier posts here and here and here. Please feel free to add your ideas, experiences or reactions by commenting on […]

  9. Graham & Dodd on today’s market « IR Café Says:

    […] of market history to investor relations. We expect investors in 2009 and beyond, battered by the bear market, to be much more focused on the acid test – the visibility of real earnings. And more skeptical of […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: